diff options
author | dakkar <dakkar@thenautilus.net> | 2015-12-11 12:51:57 +0000 |
---|---|---|
committer | dakkar <dakkar@thenautilus.net> | 2015-12-11 16:56:55 +0000 |
commit | fcacc6b79dd6c8af22db75ed021c284568386557 (patch) | |
tree | ec93ee3fed34d00e0c587b08b2a40f415465ff71 /src/anime/review/nadia/document.en.rest.txt | |
parent | links for anime list (diff) | |
download | thenautilus-fcacc6b79dd6c8af22db75ed021c284568386557.tar.gz thenautilus-fcacc6b79dd6c8af22db75ed021c284568386557.tar.bz2 thenautilus-fcacc6b79dd6c8af22db75ed021c284568386557.zip |
imported some more reviews
Diffstat (limited to 'src/anime/review/nadia/document.en.rest.txt')
-rw-r--r-- | src/anime/review/nadia/document.en.rest.txt | 115 |
1 files changed, 115 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/src/anime/review/nadia/document.en.rest.txt b/src/anime/review/nadia/document.en.rest.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..33702fc --- /dev/null +++ b/src/anime/review/nadia/document.en.rest.txt @@ -0,0 +1,115 @@ +================================== + Nadia - the Secret of Blue Water +================================== +:CreationDate: 2015-12-11 12:38:51 +:Id: anime/review/nadia +:tags: - anime + - review +:rating: 4 +:original: http://www.easternkicks.com/reviews/nadia-the-secret-of-blue-water-complete-collection + +There are some works of art that force you to take notice. You may not +have the knowledge, or the context, to fully appreciate the craft or +the importance or the references or whatever, but you are still caught +and gripped and you think «this is something special». And I'm not +only talking about “proper art”, paintings and sculpture and +“classical” music: comics and pop music and films can and do shine of +significance even to the clueless observer. + +I grew up with science fiction and anime. The first books I remember +reading on my own were abridged editions of Verne, and stories for +children written by Asimov and Bradbury. I know that I was watching +Yatterman and Polymar when I was four, and I remember watching Tetsujin +#28 and Arale when I was six. But the first time that something made +me stop and take notice was when I was fourteen, and I caught a +fragment of an early episode of Nadia on TV. When I was younger, I +used to watch TV most afternoons, and Italian TV at the time broadcast +plenty of Japanese animation; then, over the years, my computer +attracted more of my attention (no Internet! this was the eighties!), +and I sort of lost track of what was on TV: the fact that anime was +re-scheduled to coincide with mealtimes (as opposed to mid-afternoon) +didn't help, as my parents controlled the TV while we ate. So it was a +surprise, one evening just before dinner, while channel-surfing, to +stumble upon an animated scene that screamed «this is good, pay +attention». But my mother called, I went to dinner, and that was it. + +I actually didn't know what it was I had seen until about five years +later, during my first year at University, where I finally met other +manga and anime fans. I was finally able to watch the whole series, +and the experience only confirmed my first impression: Nadia is +special, it's an important cultural artefact. + +Of course, by that point, I also was better positioned to recognise +the various sources of inspiration and references in the work: Jules +Verne, of course, but also Ghibli's Laputa, Tatsunoko's Time Bokan +series, and to a lesser degree the ship design of Macross and Yamato. + +The references to Verne are obvious and explicit: the opening +narration in the first episode is essentially the same as the one that +opens Twenty Thousand Leagues under the Seas, there's a Captain Nemo +on a submarine called Nautilus, to say nothing of balloon travel +around the world, and mysterious islands. + +The Grandis / Sanson / Hanson trio is of course modelled after Doronjo +/ Tonzura / Boyacky and their other incarnations from Yatterman and +the other Time Bokan series. In Nadia, though, the characters are not +written as bumbling idiots, but as smart and resourceful thieves and +fraudsters, with hearts of gold. + +That a very similar group of enemies-but-not-quite is found in Laputa +(the sky pirates Dora / Charles / Henry / Luis) is almost certainly a +consequence of the original concept on which both works are based: in +the seventies, the production company Toho commissioned a young Hayao +Miyazaki to propose a few ideas for television series; the series were +never made, but on the one hand, Miyazaki used some of those concepts +in Future Boy Conan and Laputa, and on the other hand, Toho gave the +same concepts to Gainax (already famous for Honneamise and Gunbuster) +to make Nadia. So the two works are not directly inspired one from the +other, they're more two different developments of the same premise. I +always suggest watching both, to see how different people can tell +what is essentially the same story, and send very different +messages. Then you may also want to watch Disney's Atlantis, for +another different take on very similar premises. + +So, is this important cultural artefact without faults? Oh, of course +it has faults! + +For starters, it's way too long. 39 episodes are too many for almost +any story: at the time, 26 was the norm, and these days I look askance +at anything longer than 13. The probability of there being filler +episodes and useless story lines grows sharply beyond about four hours +of animation. Nadia is no exception: episodes 32-33 can be seamlessly +removed, the whole Lincoln Island sequence could be seriously +shortened, and after a while the chase / fights with the Evil Guy feel +repetitive. + +Then, the Evil Guy, Gargoyle, is not much of a character as a +caricature: very thin back-story, minimal motivation, apparently +unlimited resources, petty vengeance… mind you, Laputa's Muska and +Conan's Lepka are not much better written, but being a wide-spread +problem does not make “cardboard bad guy” less of a problem. + +There's many other issues with this series, but I feel they do not +detract much from its best feature: the characters. + +Jean is, in all aspects, a 14 year old techno-nerd. Naïf, socially +awkward, innately positivist, looking for technological solutions to +all problems… how many of us have been there? And, just like Jean, how +many have grown out of the destructive and isolating aspects of such +youth, helped by friends and loved ones? + +Nadia, orphan, adrift, a young black woman surrounded by white people, +exploited, sold, afraid of loving others. But with a strong moral +sense, a clear feeling for what's wrong and what's right, which helps +her navigate the upheaval of her world when she realises that not +everybody is out to get her, and that she can be loved. Nadia is as +close to a self-insert as you can get (Anno has stated on the record +that many aspects of her personality are based on himself), but I +can't think of any other who came out this well. Also, she's one of +the very few non-white characters in anime. + +I have already spoken of Grandis's trio, but they also work as adult +guidance and examples for Nadia and Jean, being much better at it than +the crew of the Nautilus are. + +And, finally, Marie, the little girl, who literally gets the last word. |